Round 6: Tossup 12

A court in this state granted a “saucy intruder” property rights over a fox that another hunter was pursuing in the seminal case Pierson v. Post. A shipwreck in this state caused by Carroll Towing led a judge from it to create a namesake “Formula” to evaluate negligence. A judge from this state ruled that a woman could not recover from a scale falling on her head after a train ran over a stick of dynamite due to “proximate cause” in the (*) Palsgraf case. A judge from this home state of Learned Hand joined Brandeis (10[1])and Stone to form the “Three Musketeers.” A law from this home state of Benjamin Cardozo granted a monopoly to Robert Fulton’s steamships before being invalidated in Gibbons v. Ogden. (-5[1])For 10 points, what state was sued in the case that began the “Lochner Era?” ■END■ (10[1])

ANSWER: New York [or NY]
<JG, American History> | NAFTA-Packet-6
= Average correct buzzpoint

Back to tossups

Buzzes


Summary

TournamentEditionMatchHeardConv. %Power %Neg %Avg. Buzz
2026 NAFTA at Stanford01/17/20264100%100%0%55.00
2026 NAFTA at UBC01/17/20262100%0%50%117.00
2025 NAFTA Online02/14/20264100%0%25%103.25
2026 NAFTA at Vanderbilt02/14/20263100%67%0%77.33
2025 NAFTA at Toronto09/13/20255100%60%0%81.40
2025 NAFTA at Maryland09/27/20255100%40%60%102.40
2025 NAFTA at Harvard10/04/20253100%67%0%55.33
2025 NAFTA at Oxford10/11/20254100%0%25%122.75
2025 NAFTA at Chicago11/08/2025683%33%33%92.00
2025 NAFTA at Columbia11/08/20255100%40%20%87.80
2025 NAFTA at Richmond12/20/20252100%100%0%60.50