Packet 6: Tossup 12

A court in this state granted a “saucy intruder” property rights over a fox that another hunter was (15[1])pursuing (15[1])in the seminal case Pierson v. Post. (15[1])A shipwreck in this state caused by (15[1])Carroll Towing led a judge from it to create a namesake “Formula” (15[1])to evaluate (15[1])negligence. (15[3])A (15[1])judge from this state ruled that a woman could not recover (-5[1])from a scale falling on her head after a train (15[1])ran (15[1])over (15[1])a stick (15[2])of dynamite (15[1])due to “proximate cause” in the (*) Palsgraf case. (10[1]-5[1])A judge from this home (10[1])state of Learned (-5[1])Hand (10[1]-5[1])joined Brandeis (10[3])and Stone (10[1])to form the “Three Musketeers.” A law from this home state of Benjamin Cardozo granted a monopoly to Robert (10[1])Fulton’s (10[1])steamships (10[1]-5[1])before being (10[2])invalidated in Gibbons v. Ogden. (-5[2])For 10 points, (-5[1])what state (-5[1])was sued in the case that began the “Lochner Era?” (10[1])■END■ (10[8]0[1])

ANSWER: New York [or NY]
<JG, American History> | NAFTA-Packet-6
= Average correct buzzpoint

Back to tossups

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzzpointValue
Andrew HartBHSUInvective Against Swans1715
Michael Kearneyconsumption smoothing by borrowing future big law incomeSurrealist Subcommandante Marcos be like Esto no es una pipa1815
Nathaniel HullBerkeley AStanford B2515
Jack GranahanMiddlesex County Fetty Wap Fan ClubThe Fire Neg Time3215
Jack LewisGeorgia Tech 𓂈𓆉𓃡Girls who Just Want to Have Fun + Liam4415
Vasa ClarkeMunir Siddiqui Fan Clubhttps://i.imgur.com/C6nN2FE.png4615
Eric BobrowUntitled by Alexander McQueen by Premeditated Chaos by Alexander McQueen by Percival EverettHabitat 674715
Sean SmileyContessa DoraMike and Psmith4715
Stephen LiuTeam 8Constans Constantius and Constantine Jr.4715
Matt WeinerIt's something unpredictable/that in the end is right/please refrain from e-mailing my wifePolish Orthographers Posting Their Łs4815
Chris RayMaryland F♯ A♯ ∞Penn State59-5
S.A. ShenoyThe Umayyad Caliphate be like REPEAL NAPHTHATennessee A6915
Grant LiShipping Down from BallstonThe "C" Team7015
JinAh Kim(give me an) ANSWER: die for baseballThe tram is not in service; please use the moving walkway.7115
Noah ChinDavid Foster GromitCopán Seethe7315
Eric ChenNot Old! (Old)Team 77315
Andrew ZengStanford ABerkeley B7515
Akshar GoyalExecute Order 6 7Chicago !A83-5
Monit Karmakar[Redacted]WashU8310
Noah SheidlowerNoah Sheidlower Six Quizbowlers in Search of Owen Minmo8810
Dillon GeorgeCatholic University ARosslyn Academic Team91-5
Jakob MyersIndianaIn the Mood for Transportation Equipment92-5
Agnijo BanerjeeDielectrical MaterialismDour Straits9210
Ryan RosenbergNYU ANegged Five Times in a Yellow Cab Against the Gottis and Gambinos9410
Michael CoatesMaybe EverLex9410
Alan ZhangAbbas I founded the AbbasidsThe Unbearable Heaviness of History Players9410
Malcolm McIntyreW&L+FriendSt. Marx9610
Andrew Ullsperger1000000 DelinquentsNorthwestern11510
Walter ZhangCapital One in the Twenty-First CenturyThe Saint-Straw that Broke the Camille's Back11610
Tracy MirkinMuscle Mass Extinction EventQuebecois Olga Tokarczuk be like 'freins de jacob interdits'11710
Evan Tingfour high school generalists shock natives with fluent stock in Tocharian BThe Worst Trade Deal in the History of Trade Deals117-5
Ben Russell JonesThe Third Time when she was Given to Answer the Hard and the Easy, and Answered Only the EasyNo Country for Old Quizzers11910
Eric MukherjeeAna Pauker? I hardly know her!Say It Ain't Zhou11910
Jim FanUNC CharityJHU124-5
Sriram SusarlaUBC BUBC A124-5
George CharlsonH Charlson's Washed Up ScrubsA Neg of Beauty is a Joy Forever127-5
Kelvin NiNYU B or not NYU B (that is the question)Untitled Keyal Team129-5
Iain CarpenterPenn StateMaryland F♯ A♯ ∞13910
John MarvinChicago !AExecute Order 6 71400
Josh KochIn the Mood for Transportation EquipmentIndiana14010
Rahul KeyalUntitled Keyal TeamNYU B or not NYU B (that is the question)14010
David BassJHUUNC Charity14010
Cole HartungRosslyn Academic TeamCatholic University A14010
Billy BusseThe Worst Trade Deal in the History of Trade Dealsfour high school generalists shock natives with fluent stock in Tocharian B14010
Zachary FosterA Neg of Beauty is a Joy ForeverH Charlson's Washed Up Scrubs14010
Ben LaFondVacuous TortoiseC R A B S14010
Matthew WangUBC AUBC B14010

Summary

TournamentEditionMatchHeardConv. %Power %Neg %Avg. Buzz
2026 NAFTA at Stanford01/17/20264100%100%0%55.00
2026 NAFTA at UBC01/17/20262100%0%50%117.00
2025 NAFTA Online02/14/20264100%0%25%103.25
2026 NAFTA at Vanderbilt02/14/20263100%67%0%77.33
2025 NAFTA at Toronto09/13/20255100%60%0%81.40
2025 NAFTA at Maryland09/27/20255100%40%60%102.40
2025 NAFTA at Harvard10/04/20253100%67%0%55.33
2025 NAFTA at Oxford10/11/20254100%0%25%122.75
2025 NAFTA at Chicago11/08/2025683%33%33%92.00
2025 NAFTA at Columbia11/08/20255100%40%20%87.80
2025 NAFTA at Richmond12/20/20252100%100%0%60.50